I finally got the chance to see Eat, Pray, Love over the weekend and would like to defend the movie, the book, the author (Elizabeth Gilbert) and even the actress playing the author (Julia Roberts).
First off, I read the book several months ago before watching the movie and didn’t think Gilbert’s attitude in the book was self-centered or hedonistic at all. Let’s be clear about one thing – Gilbert financed the trip herself. She received a major book advance for the premise of Eat, Pray, Love and traveled around the world with that money.
Why did someone like Gilbert receive all that money? Because she had proved in the past that she was actually a good writer. She was a good writer who was not only capable of stringing together a coherent sentence but also received critical acclaim and awards for her short stories, long stories, and books.
Gilbert did not travel around the world on trust fund money from her WASPy parents or wealthy husband. Gilbert wasn’t some rich, white woman who suddenly decided to go to Italy, India, and Bali on a whim because she was rich and white. Nearly every review I’ve read about the movie criticizes Gilbert for being a “rich, white American” who didn’t have a care in the world and was able to do what she did because she was rich and white. Did I mention how rich and white she is?
No, the book advance was money Gilbert had earned on her own and she was entitled to do whatever the hell she wanted with it.
Second, the man she ended up meeting in Bali – Felipe – looked NOTHING like actor Javier Bardem. Columbia Pictures took some pretty extreme measures in casting Bardem to portray a man who, in real life, was 17 years older than Gilbert and did not look like a spring chicken or a sexy Brazilian man. I bet you nearly everyone would have shut up about how unfair it was that Gilbert met the love of her life in Bali if they knew what he looked like in reality.
Third, I get the feeling that most people are unconsciously more annoyed with actress Julia Roberts than the (real-life) character of Elizabeth Gilbert herself. When I say Julia Roberts, you immediately think of romantic comedies. As a female, you become irritated because her romantic comedies make you feel bad about your own life (and that lazy boyfriend/husband of yours). As a male, you become irritated because every time your girlfriend/wife watches a Julia Roberts movie, she gets in a bad mood afterward over why you don’t act like the men wooing Ms. Roberts. I swear, it’s almost like watching Pavlov’s dogs when I mention Julia Roberts.
The instant you heard Roberts’ name attached to Eat, Pray, Love you thought, “Oh GOD, another romantic comedy that will make me feel nauseous and bad about my own love life.” You then went into the film with that mentality without even considering the fact that the themes in Gilbert’s memoir were maybe more significant than what is usually presented in a Julia Roberts movie.
And they were more significant. I personally admire Elizabeth Gilbert (the author) for ending a marriage that she knew wasn’t working. Rather than live her life in misery, knowing that her growing unhappiness would eventually not only be a detriment to her mental and physical health but her husband’s as well, Gilbert chose to do a very difficult thing. How many people do you know would “stick it out” and hope that things get better when they already know deep down that it won’t and that it would only be a matter of time before things progressed from bad to worse?
Despite how indulgent that year abroad may have seemed, Gilbert was doing it because she did feel like she needed to get away and “discover” who she was. (And, let’s not forget, she had her own money to do so). I liked the fact that she stated upfront – “Since I was 15, I’ve been with a guy. I really need to be by myself for a while and get my shit together.”
A side note about the movie and Julia Roberts – both really weren’t that bad. Roberts may like to play it safe, but she does a good job in her roles. The movie never got over the top and made me want to hurl on the person sitting in front of me. I think Ryan Murphy did a fine job with this project.
The next time someone complains about Eat, Pray, Love, ask them for a legit reason as to why they didn’t like the movie and then tell them to go read her book.
Trailer for Eat, Pray, Love:











